A coalgebraic semantics for causality in Petri nets

In this paper we revisit some pioneering efforts to equip Petri nets with compact operational models for expressing causality. The models we propose have a bisimilarity relation and a minimal representative for each equivalence class, and they can be fully explained as coalgebras on a presheaf category on an index category of partial orders. First, we provide a set-theoretic model in the form of a causal case graph, that is a labeled transition system where states and transitions represent markings and firings of the net, respectively, and are equipped with causal information. Most importantly, each state has a poset representing causal dependencies among past events. Our first result shows the correspondence with behavior structure semantics as proposed by Trakhtenbrot and Rabinovich. Causal case graphs may be infinitely-branching and have infinitely many states, but we show how they can be refined to get an equivalent finitely-branching model. In it, states only keep the most recent causes for each token, are up to isomorphism, and are equipped with a symmetry, i.e., a group of poset isomorphisms. Symmetries are essential for the existence of a minimal, often finite-state, model. This first part requires no knowledge of category theory. The next step is constructing a coalgebraic model. We exploit the fact that events can be represented as names, and event generation as name generation. Thus we can apply the Fiore-Turi framework, where the semantics of nominal calculi are modeled as coalgebras over presheaves. We model causal relations as a suitable category of posets with action labels, and generation of new events with causal dependencies as an endofunctor on this category. Presheaves indexed by labeled posets represent the functorial association between states and their causal information. Then we define a well-behaved category of coalgebras. Our coalgebraic model is still infinite-state, but we exploit the equivalence between coalgebras over a class of presheaves and History Dependent automata to derive a compact representation, which is equivalent to our set-theoretical compact model. Remarkably, state reduction is automatically performed along the equivalence.