In 2008 we published the first set of guidelines for standardizing research in autophagy. Since then, research on this topic has continued to accelerate, and many new scientists have entered the field. Our knowledge base and relevant new technologies have also been expanding. Accordingly, it is important to update these guidelines for monitoring autophagy in different organisms. Various reviews have described the range of assays that have been used for this purpose. Nevertheless, there continues to be confusion regarding acceptable methods to measure autophagy, especially in multicellular eukaryotes. A key point that needs to be emphasized is that there is a difference between measurements that monitor the numbers or volume of autophagic elements (e.g., autophagosomes or autolysosomes) at any stage of the autophagic process vs. those that measure flux through the autophagy pathway (i.e., the complete process); thus, a block in macroautophagy that results in autophagosome accumulation needs to be differentiated from stimuli that result in increased autophagic activity, defined as increased autophagy induction coupled with increased delivery to, and degradation within, lysosomes (in most higher eukaryotes and some protists such as Dictyostelium) or the vacuole (in plants and fungi). In other words, it is especially important that investigators new to the field understand that the appearance of more autophagosomes does not necessarily equate with more autophagy. In fact, in many cases, autophagosomes accumulate because of a block in trafficking to lysosomes without a concomitant change in autophagosome biogenesis, whereas an increase in autolysosomes may reflect a reduction in degradative activity. Here, we present a set of guidelines for the selection and interpretation of methods for use by investigators who aim to examine macroautophagy and related processes, as well as for reviewers who need to provide realistic and reasonable critiques of papers that are focused on these processes. These guidelines are not meant to be a formulaic set of rules, because the appropriate assays depend in part on the question being asked and the system being used. In addition, we emphasize that no individual assay is guaranteed to be the most appropriate one in every situation, and we strongly recommend the use of multiple assays to monitor autophagy. In these guidelines, we consider these various methods of assessing autophagy and what information can, or cannot, be obtained from them. Finally, by discussing the merits and limits of particular autophagy assays, we hope to encourage technical innovation in the field.

Guidelines for the use and interpretation of assays for monitoring autophagy.

DE TATA, VINCENZO;FORNAI, FRANCESCO;MARCHETTI, PIERO;MASINI, MATILDE;
2012

Abstract

In 2008 we published the first set of guidelines for standardizing research in autophagy. Since then, research on this topic has continued to accelerate, and many new scientists have entered the field. Our knowledge base and relevant new technologies have also been expanding. Accordingly, it is important to update these guidelines for monitoring autophagy in different organisms. Various reviews have described the range of assays that have been used for this purpose. Nevertheless, there continues to be confusion regarding acceptable methods to measure autophagy, especially in multicellular eukaryotes. A key point that needs to be emphasized is that there is a difference between measurements that monitor the numbers or volume of autophagic elements (e.g., autophagosomes or autolysosomes) at any stage of the autophagic process vs. those that measure flux through the autophagy pathway (i.e., the complete process); thus, a block in macroautophagy that results in autophagosome accumulation needs to be differentiated from stimuli that result in increased autophagic activity, defined as increased autophagy induction coupled with increased delivery to, and degradation within, lysosomes (in most higher eukaryotes and some protists such as Dictyostelium) or the vacuole (in plants and fungi). In other words, it is especially important that investigators new to the field understand that the appearance of more autophagosomes does not necessarily equate with more autophagy. In fact, in many cases, autophagosomes accumulate because of a block in trafficking to lysosomes without a concomitant change in autophagosome biogenesis, whereas an increase in autolysosomes may reflect a reduction in degradative activity. Here, we present a set of guidelines for the selection and interpretation of methods for use by investigators who aim to examine macroautophagy and related processes, as well as for reviewers who need to provide realistic and reasonable critiques of papers that are focused on these processes. These guidelines are not meant to be a formulaic set of rules, because the appropriate assays depend in part on the question being asked and the system being used. In addition, we emphasize that no individual assay is guaranteed to be the most appropriate one in every situation, and we strongly recommend the use of multiple assays to monitor autophagy. In these guidelines, we consider these various methods of assessing autophagy and what information can, or cannot, be obtained from them. Finally, by discussing the merits and limits of particular autophagy assays, we hope to encourage technical innovation in the field.
Klionsky, Dj; Abdalla, Fc; Abeliovich, H; Abraham, Rt; Acevedo Arozena, A; Adeli, K; Agholme, L; Agnello, M; Agostinis, P; Aguirre Ghiso, Ja; Ahn, Hj; Ait Mohamed, O; Ait Si Ali, S; Akematsu, T; Akira, S; Al Younes, Hm; Al Zeer, Ma; Albert, Ml; Albin, Rl; Alegre Abarrategui, J; Aleo, Mf; Alirezaei, M; Almasan, A; Almonte Becerril, M; Amano, A; Amaravadi, R; Amarnath, S; Amer, Ao; Andrieu Abadie, N; Anantharam, V; Ann, Dk; Anoopkumar Dukie, S; Aoki, H; Apostolova, N; Arancia, G; Aris, Jp; Asanuma, K; Asare, Ny; Ashida, H; Askanas, V; Askew, Ds; Auberger, P; Baba, M; Backues, Sk; Baehrecke, Eh; Bahr, Ba; Bai, Xy; Bailly, Y; Baiocchi, R; Baldini, G; Balduini, W; Ballabio, A; Bamber, Ba; Bampton, Et; Bánhegyi, G; Bartholomew, Cr; Bassham, Dc; Bast RC, Jr; Batoko, H; Bay, Bh; Beau, I; Béchet, Dm; Begley, Tj; Behl, C; Behrends, C; Bekri, S; Bellaire, B; Bendall, Lj; Benetti, L; Berliocchi, L; Bernardi, H; Bernassola, F; Besteiro, S; Bhatia Kissova, I; Bi, X; Biard Piechaczyk, M; Blum, Js; Boise, Lh; Bonaldo, P; Boone, Dl; Bornhauser, Bc; Bortoluci, Kr; Bossis, I; Bost, F; Bourquin, Jp; Boya, P; Boyer Guittaut, M; Bozhkov, Pv; Brady, Nr; Brancolini, C; Brech, A; Brenman, Je; Brennand, A; Bresnick, Eh; Brest, P; Bridges, D; Bristol, Ml; Brookes, Ps; Brown, Ej; Brumell, Jh; Brunetti Pierri, N; Brunk, Ut; Bulman, De; Bultman, Sj; Bultynck, G; Burbulla, Lf; Bursch, W; Butchar, Jp; Buzgariu, W; Bydlowski, Sp; Cadwell, K; Cahová, M; Cai, D; Cai, J; Cai, Q; Calabretta, B; Calvo Garrido, J; Camougrand, N; Campanella, M; Campos Salinas, J; Candi, E; Cao, L; Caplan, Ab; Carding, Sr; Cardoso, Sm; Carew, Js; Carlin, Cr; Carmignac, V; Carneiro, La; Carra, S; Caruso, Ra; Casari, G; Casas, C; Castino, R; Cebollero, E; Cecconi, F; Celli, J; Chaachouay, H; Chae, Hj; Chai, Cy; Chan, Dc; Chan, Ey; Chang, Rc; Che, Cm; Chen, Cc; Chen, Gc; Chen, Gq; Chen, M; Chen, Q; Chen, Ss; Chen, W; Chen, X; Chen, X; Chen, X; Chen, Yg; Chen, Y; Chen, Y; Chen, Yj; Chen, Z; Cheng, A; Cheng, Ch; Cheng, Y; Cheong, H; Cheong, Jh; Cherry, S; Chess Williams, R; Cheung, Zh; Chevet, E; Chiang, Hl; Chiarelli, R; Chiba, T; Chin, Ls; Chiou, Sh; Chisari, Fv; Cho, Ch; Cho, Dh; Choi, Am; Choi, D; Choi, Ks; Choi, Me; Chouaib, S; Choubey, D; Choubey, V; Chu, Ct; Chuang, Th; Chueh, Sh; Chun, T; Chwae, Yj; Chye, Ml; Ciarcia, R; Ciriolo, Mr; Clague, Mj; Clark, Rs; Clarke, Pg; Clarke, R; Codogno, P; Coller, Ha; Colombo, Mi; Comincini, S; Condello, M; Condorelli, F; Cookson, Mr; Coombs, Gh; Coppens, I; Corbalan, R; Cossart, P; Costelli, P; Costes, S; Coto Montes, A; Couve, E; Coxon, Fp; Cregg, Jm; Crespo, Jl; Cronjé, Mj; Cuervo, Am; Cullen, Jj; Czaja, Mj; D'Amelio, M; Darfeuille Michaud, A; Davids, Lm; Davies, Fe; De Felici, M; de Groot, Jf; de Haan, Ca; De Martino, L; De Milito, A; DE TATA, Vincenzo; Debnath, J; Degterev, A; Dehay, B; Delbridge, Lm; Demarchi, F; Deng, Yz; Dengjel, J; Dent, P; Denton, D; Deretic, V; Desai, Sd; Devenish, Rj; Di Gioacchino, M; Di Paolo, G; Di Pietro, C; Díaz Araya, G; Díaz Laviada, I; Diaz Meco, Mt; Diaz Nido, J; Dikic, I; Dinesh Kumar, Sp; Ding, Wx; Distelhorst, Cw; Diwan, A; Djavaheri Mergny, M; Dokudovskaya, S; Dong, Z; Dorsey, Fc; Dosenko, V; Dowling, Jj; Doxsey, S; Dreux, M; Drew, Me; Duan, Q; Duchosal, Ma; Duff, K; Dugail, I; Durbeej, M; Duszenko, M; Edelstein, Cl; Edinger, Al; Egea, G; Eichinger, L; Eissa, Nt; Ekmekcioglu, S; El Deiry, Ws; Elazar, Z; Elgendy, M; Ellerby, Lm; Eng, Ke; Engelbrecht, Am; Engelender, S; Erenpreisa, J; Escalante, R; Esclatine, A; Eskelinen, El; Espert, L; Espina, V; Fan, H; Fan, J; Fan, Qw; Fan, Z; Fang, S; Fang, Y; Fanto, M; Fanzani, A; Farkas, T; Farré, Jc; Faure, M; Fechheimer, M; Feng, Cg; Feng, J; Feng, Q; Feng, Y; Fésüs, L; Feuer, R; Figueiredo Pereira, Me; Fimia, Gm; Fingar, Dc; Finkbeiner, S; Finkel, T; Finley, Kd; Fiorito, F; Fisher, Ea; Fisher, Pb; Flajolet, M; Florez McClure, Ml; Florio, S; Fon, Ea; Fornai, Francesco; Fortunato, F; Fotedar, R; Fowler, Dh; Fox, Hs; Franco, R; Frankel, Lb; Fransen, M; Fuentes, Jm; Fueyo, J; Fujii, J; Fujisaki, K; Fujita, E; Fukuda, M; Furukawa, Rh; Gaestel, M; Gailly, P; Gajewska, M; Galliot, B; Galy, V; Ganesh, S; Ganetzky, B; Ganley, Ig; Gao, Fb; Gao, Gf; Gao, J; Garcia, L; Garcia Manero, G; Garcia Marcos, M; Garmyn, M; Gartel, Al; Gatti, E; Gautel, M; Gawriluk, Tr; Gegg, Me; Geng, J; Germain, M; Gestwicki, Je; Gewirtz, Da; Ghavami, S; Ghosh, P; Giammarioli, Am; Giatromanolaki, An; Gibson, Sb; Gilkerson, Rw; Ginger, Ml; Ginsberg, Hn; Golab, J; Goligorsky, Ms; Golstein, P; Gomez Manzano, C; Goncu, E; Gongora, C; Gonzalez, Cd; Gonzalez, R; González Estévez, C; González Polo, Ra; Gonzalez Rey, E; Gorbunov, Nv; Gorski, S; Goruppi, S; Gottlieb, Ra; Gozuacik, D; Granato, Ge; Grant, Gd; Green, Kn; Gregorc, A; Gros, F; Grose, C; Grunt, Tw; Gual, P; Guan, Jl; Guan, Kl; Guichard, Sm; Gukovskaya, As; Gukovsky, I; Gunst, J; Gustafsson, Ab; Halayko, Aj; Hale, An; Halonen, Sk; Hamasaki, M; Han, F; Han, T; Hancock, Mk; Hansen, M; Harada, H; Harada, M; Hardt, Se; Harper, Jw; Harris, Al; Harris, J; Harris, Sd; Hashimoto, M; Haspel, Ja; Hayashi, S; Hazelhurst, La; He, C; He, Yw; Hébert, Mj; Heidenreich, Ka; Helfrich, Mh; Helgason, Gv; Henske, Ep; Herman, B; Herman, Pk; Hetz, C; Hilfiker, S; Hill, Ja; Hocking, Lj; Hofman, P; Hofmann, Tg; Höhfeld, J; Holyoake, Tl; Hong, Mh; Hood, Da; Hotamisligil, Gs; Houwerzijl, Ej; Høyer Hansen, M; Hu, B; Hu, Ca; Hu, Hm; Hua, Y; Huang, C; Huang, J; Huang, S; Huang, Wp; Huber, Tb; Huh, Wk; Hung, Th; Hupp, Tr; Hur, Gm; Hurley, Jb; Hussain, Sn; Hussey, Pj; Hwang, Jj; Hwang, S; Ichihara, A; Ilkhanizadeh, S; Inoki, K; Into, T; Iovane, V; Iovanna, Jl; Ip, Ny; Isaka, Y; Ishida, H; Isidoro, C; Isobe, K; Iwasaki, A; Izquierdo, M; Izumi, Y; Jaakkola, Pm; Jäättelä, M; Jackson, Gr; Jackson, Wt; Janji, B; Jendrach, M; Jeon, Jh; Jeung, Eb; Jiang, H; Jiang, H; Jiang, Jx; Jiang, M; Jiang, Q; Jiang, X; Jiang, X; Jiménez, A; Jin, M; Jin, S; Joe, Co; Johansen, T; Johnson, De; Johnson, Gv; Jones, Nl; Joseph, B; Joseph, Sk; Joubert, Am; Juhász, G; Juillerat Jeanneret, L; Jung, Ch; Jung, Yk; Kaarniranta, K; Kaasik, A; Kabuta, T; Kadowaki, M; Kagedal, K; Kamada, Y; Kaminskyy, Vo; Kampinga, Hh; Kanamori, H; Kang, C; Kang, Kb; Kang, Ki; Kang, R; Kang, Ya; Kanki, T; Kanneganti, Td; Kanno, H; Kanthasamy, Ag; Kanthasamy, A; Karantza, V; Kaushal, Gp; Kaushik, S; Kawazoe, Y; Ke, Py; Kehrl, Jh; Kelekar, A; Kerkhoff, C; Kessel, Dh; Khalil, H; Kiel, Ja; Kiger, Aa; Kihara, A; Kim, Dr; Kim, Dh; Kim, Dh; Kim, Ek; Kim, Hr; Kim, Js; Kim, Jh; Kim, Jc; Kim, Jk; Kim, Pk; Kim, Sw; Kim, Ys; Kim, Y; Kimchi, A; Kimmelman, Ac; King, Js; Kinsella, Tj; Kirkin, V; Kirshenbaum, La; Kitamoto, K; Kitazato, K; Klein, L; Klimecki, Wt; Klucken, J; Knecht, E; Ko, Bc; Koch, Jc; Koga, H; Koh, Jy; Koh, Yh; Koike, M; Komatsu, M; Kominami, E; Kong, Hj; Kong, Wj; Korolchuk, Vi; Kotake, Y; Koukourakis, Mi; Kouri Flores, Jb; Kovács, Al; Kraft, C; Krainc, D; Krämer, H; Kretz Remy, C; Krichevsky, Am; Kroemer, G; Krüger, R; Krut, O; Ktistakis, Nt; Kuan, Cy; Kucharczyk, R; Kumar, A; Kumar, R; Kumar, S; Kundu, M; Kung, Hj; Kurz, T; Kwon, Hj; La Spada, Ar; Lafont, F; Lamark, T; Landry, J; Lane, Jd; Lapaquette, P; Laporte, Jf; László, L; Lavandero, S; Lavoie, Jn; Layfield, R; Lazo, Pa; Le, W; Le Cam, L; Ledbetter, Dj; Lee, Aj; Lee, Bw; Lee, Gm; Lee, J; Lee, Jh; Lee, M; Lee, Ms; Lee, Sh; Leeuwenburgh, C; Legembre, P; Legouis, R; Lehmann, M; Lei, Hy; Lei, Qy; Leib, Da; Leiro, J; Lemasters, Jj; Lemoine, A; Lesniak, Ms; Lev, D; Levenson, Vv; Levine, B; Levy, E; Li, F; Li, Jl; Li, L; Li, S; Li, W; Li, Xj; Li, Yb; Li, Yp; Liang, C; Liang, Q; Liao, Yf; Liberski, Pp; Lieberman, A; Lim, Hj; Lim, Kl; Lim, K; Lin, Cf; Lin, Fc; Lin, J; Lin, Jd; Lin, K; Lin, Ww; Lin, Wc; Lin, Yl; Linden, R; Lingor, P; Lippincott Schwartz, J; Lisanti, Mp; Liton, Pb; Liu, B; Liu, Cf; Liu, K; Liu, L; Liu, Qa; Liu, W; Liu, Yc; Liu, Y; Lockshin, Ra; Lok, Cn; Lonial, S; Loos, B; Lopez Berestein, G; López Otín, C; Lossi, L; Lotze, Mt; Lőw, P; Lu, B; Lu, B; Lu, B; Lu, Z; Luciano, F; Lukacs, Nw; Lund, Ah; Lynch Day, Ma; Ma, Y; Macian, F; Mackeigan, Jp; Macleod, Kf; Madeo, F; Maiuri, L; Maiuri, Mc; Malagoli, D; Malicdan, Mc; Malorni, W; Man, N; Mandelkow, Em; Manon, S; Manov, I; Mao, K; Mao, X; Mao, Z; Marambaud, P; Marazziti, D; Marcel, Yl; Marchbank, K; Marchetti, Piero; Marciniak, Sj; Marcondes, M; Mardi, M; Marfe, G; Mariño, G; Markaki, M; Marten, Mr; Martin, Sj; Martinand Mari, C; Martinet, W; Martinez Vicente, M; Masini, Matilde; Matarrese, P; Matsuo, S; Matteoni, R; Mayer, A; Mazure, Nm; Mcconkey, Dj; Mcconnell, Mj; Mcdermott, C; Mcdonald, C; Mcinerney, Gm; Mckenna, Sl; Mclaughlin, B; Mclean, Pj; Mcmaster, Cr; Mcquibban, Ga; Meijer, Aj; Meisler, Mh; Meléndez, A; Melia, Tj; Melino, G; Mena, Ma; Menendez, Ja; Menna Barreto, Rf; Menon, Mb; Menzies, Fm; Mercer, Ca; Merighi, A; Merry, De; Meschini, S; Meyer, Cg; Meyer, Tf; Miao, Cy; Miao, Jy; Michels, Pa; Michiels, C; Mijaljica, D; Milojkovic, A; Minucci, S; Miracco, C; Miranti, Ck; Mitroulis, I; Miyazawa, K; Mizushima, N; Mograbi, B; Mohseni, S; Molero, X; Mollereau, B; Mollinedo, F; Momoi, T; Monastyrska, I; Monick, Mm; Monteiro, Mj; Moore, Mn; Mora, R; Moreau, K; Moreira, Pi; Moriyasu, Y; Moscat, J; Mostowy, S; Mottram, Jc; Motyl, T; Moussa, Ce; Müller, S; Muller, S; Münger, K; Münz, C; Murphy, Lo; Murphy, Me; Musarò, A; Mysorekar, I; Nagata, E; Nagata, K; Nahimana, A; Nair, U; Nakagawa, T; Nakahira, K; Nakano, H; Nakatogawa, H; Nanjundan, M; Naqvi, Ni; Narendra, Dp; Narita, M; Navarro, M; Nawrocki, St; Nazarko, Ty; Nemchenko, A; Netea, Mg; Neufeld, Tp; Ney, Pa; Nezis, Ip; Nguyen, Hp; Nie, D; Nishino, I; Nislow, C; Nixon, Ra; Noda, T; Noegel, Aa; Nogalska, A; Noguchi, S; Notterpek, L; Novak, I; Nozaki, T; Nukina, N; Nürnberger, T; Nyfeler, B; Obara, K; Oberley, Td; Oddo, S; Ogawa, M; Ohashi, T; Okamoto, K; Oleinick, Nl; Oliver, Fj; Olsen, Lj; Olsson, S; Opota, O; Osborne, Tf; Ostrander, Gk; Otsu, K; Ou, Jh; Ouimet, M; Overholtzer, M; Ozpolat, B; Paganetti, P; Pagnini, U; Pallet, N; Palmer, Ge; Palumbo, C; Pan, T; Panaretakis, T; Pandey, Ub; Papackova, Z; Papassideri, I; Paris, I; Park, J; Park, Ok; Parys, Jb; Parzych, Kr; Patschan, S; Patterson, C; Pattingre, S; Pawelek, Jm; Peng, J; Perlmutter, Dh; Perrotta, I; Perry, G; Pervaiz, S; Peter, M; Peters, Gj; Petersen, M; Petrovski, G; Phang, Jm; Piacentini, M; Pierre, P; Pierrefite Carle, V; Pierron, G; Pinkas Kramarski, R; Piras, A; Piri, N; Platanias, Lc; Pöggeler, S; Poirot, M; Poletti, A; Poüs, C; Pozuelo Rubio, M; Prætorius Ibba, M; Prasad, A; Prescott, M; Priault, M; Produit Zengaffinen, N; Progulske Fox, A; Proikas Cezanne, T; Przedborski, S; Przyklenk, K; Puertollano, R; Puyal, J; Qian, Sb; Qin, L; Qin, Zh; Quaggin, Se; Raben, N; Rabinowich, H; Rabkin, Sw; Rahman, I; Rami, A; Ramm, G; Randall, G; Randow, F; Rao, Va; Rathmell, Jc; Ravikumar, B; Ray, Sk; Reed, Bh; Reed, Jc; Reggiori, F; Régnier Vigouroux, A; Reichert, As; Reiners JJ, Jr; Reiter, Rj; Ren, J; Revuelta, Jl; Rhodes, Cj; Ritis, K; Rizzo, E; Robbins, J; Roberge, M; Roca, H; Roccheri, Mc; Rocchi, S; Rodemann, Hp; Rodríguez de Córdoba, S; Rohrer, B; Roninson, Ib; Rosen, K; Rost Roszkowska, Mm; Rouis, M; Rouschop, Km; Rovetta, F; Rubin, Bp; Rubinsztein, Dc; Ruckdeschel, K; Rucker EB, 3rd; Rudich, A; Rudolf, E; Ruiz Opazo, N; Russo, R; Rusten, Te; Ryan, Km; Ryter, Sw; Sabatini, Dm; Sadoshima, J; Saha, T; Saitoh, T; Sakagami, H; Sakai, Y; Salekdeh, Gh; Salomoni, P; Salvaterra, Pm; Salvesen, G; Salvioli, R; Sanchez, Am; Sánchez Alcázar, Ja; Sánchez Prieto, R; Sandri, M; Sankar, U; Sansanwal, P; Santambrogio, L; Saran, S; Sarkar, S; Sarwal, M; Sasakawa, C; Sasnauskiene, A; Sass, M; Sato, K; Sato, M; Schapira, Ah; Scharl, M; Schätzl, Hm; Scheper, W; Schiaffino, S; Schneider, C; Schneider, Me; Schneider Stock, R; Schoenlein, Pv; Schorderet, Df; Schüller, C; Schwartz, Gk; Scorrano, L; Sealy, L; Seglen, Po; Segura Aguilar, J; Seiliez, I; Seleverstov, O; Sell, C; Seo, Jb; Separovic, D; Setaluri, V; Setoguchi, T; Settembre, C; Shacka, Jj; Shanmugam, M; Shapiro, Im; Shaulian, E; Shaw, Rj; Shelhamer, Jh; Shen, Hm; Shen, Wc; Sheng, Zh; Shi, Y; Shibuya, K; Shidoji, Y; Shieh, Jj; Shih, Cm; Shimada, Y; Shimizu, S; Shintani, T; Shirihai, Os; Shore, Gc; Sibirny, Aa; Sidhu, Sb; Sikorska, B; Silva Zacarin, Ec; Simmons, A; Simon, Ak; Simon, Hu; Simone, C; Simonsen, A; Sinclair, Da; Singh, R; Sinha, D; Sinicrope, Fa; Sirko, A; Siu, Pm; Sivridis, E; Skop, V; Skulachev, Vp; Slack, Rs; Smaili, Ss; Smith, Dr; Soengas, Ms; Soldati, T; Song, X; Sood, Ak; Soong, Tw; Sotgia, F; Spector, Sa; Spies, Cd; Springer, W; Srinivasula, Sm; Stefanis, L; Steffan, Js; Stendel, R; Stenmark, H; Stephanou, A; Stern, St; Sternberg, C; Stork, B; Strålfors, P; Subauste, Cs; Sui, X; Sulzer, D; Sun, J; Sun, Sy; Sun, Zj; Sung, Jj; Suzuki, K; Suzuki, T; Swanson, Ms; Swanton, C; Sweeney, St; Sy, Lk; Szabadkai, G; Tabas, I; Taegtmeyer, H; Tafani, M; Takács Vellai, K; Takano, Y; Takegawa, K; Takemura, G; Takeshita, F; Talbot, Nj; Tan, Ks; Tanaka, K; Tanaka, K; Tang, D; Tang, D; Tanida, I; Tannous, Ba; Tavernarakis, N; Taylor, Gs; Taylor, Ga; Taylor, Jp; Terada, Ls; Terman, A; Tettamanti, G; Thevissen, K; Thompson, Cb; Thorburn, A; Thumm, M; Tian, F; Tian, Y; Tocchini Valentini, G; Tolkovsky, Am; Tomino, Y; Tönges, L; Tooze, Sa; Tournier, C; Tower, J; Towns, R; Trajkovic, V; Travassos, Lh; Tsai, Tf; Tschan, Mp; Tsubata, T; Tsung, A; Turk, B; Turner, Ls; Tyagi, Sc; Uchiyama, Y; Ueno, T; Umekawa, M; Umemiya Shirafuji, R; Unni, Vk; Vaccaro, Mi; Valente, Em; Van den Berghe, G; van der Klei, Ij; van Doorn, W; van Dyk, Lf; van Egmond, M; van Grunsven, La; Vandenabeele, P; Vandenberghe, Wp; Vanhorebeek, I; Vaquero, Ec; Velasco, G; Vellai, T; Vicencio, Jm; Vierstra, Rd; Vila, M; Vindis, C; Viola, G; Viscomi, Mt; Voitsekhovskaja, Ov; von Haefen, C; Votruba, M; Wada, K; Wade Martins, R; Walker, Cl; Walsh, Cm; Walter, J; Wan, Xb; Wang, A; Wang, C; Wang, D; Wang, F; Wang, F; Wang, G; Wang, H; Wang, Hg; Wang, Hd; Wang, J; Wang, K; Wang, M; Wang, Rc; Wang, X; Wang, X; Wang, Yj; Wang, Y; Wang, Z; Wang, Zc; Wang, Z; Wansink, Dg; Ward, Dm; Watada, H; Waters, Sl; Webster, P; Wei, L; Weihl, Cc; Weiss, Wa; Welford, Sm; Wen, Lp; Whitehouse, Ca; Whitton, Jl; Whitworth, Aj; Wileman, T; Wiley, Jw; Wilkinson, S; Willbold, D; Williams, Rl; Williamson, Pr; Wouters, Bg; Wu, C; Wu, Dc; Wu, Wk; Wyttenbach, A; Xavier, Rj; Xi, Z; Xia, P; Xiao, G; Xie, Z; Xie, Z; Xu, Dz; Xu, J; Xu, L; Xu, X; Yamamoto, A; Yamamoto, A; Yamashina, S; Yamashita, M; Yan, X; Yanagida, M; Yang, Ds; Yang, E; Yang, Jm; Yang, Sy; Yang, W; Yang, Wy; Yang, Z; Yao, Mc; Yao, Tp; Yeganeh, B; Yen, Wl; Yin, Jj; Yin, Xm; Yoo, Oj; Yoon, G; Yoon, Sy; Yorimitsu, T; Yoshikawa, Y; Yoshimori, T; Yoshimoto, K; You, Hj; Youle, Rj; Younes, A; Yu, L; Yu, L; Yu, Sw; Yu, Wh; Yuan, Zm; Yue, Z; Yun, Ch; Yuzaki, M; Zabirnyk, O; Silva Zacarin, E; Zacks, D; Zacksenhaus, E; Zaffaroni, N; Zakeri, Z; Zeh HJ, 3rd; Zeitlin, So; Zhang, H; Zhang, Hl; Zhang, J; Zhang, Jp; Zhang, L; Zhang, L; Zhang, My; Zhang, Xd; Zhao, M; Zhao, Yf; Zhao, Y; Zhao, Zj; Zheng, X; Zhivotovsky, B; Zhong, Q; Zhou, Cz; Zhu, C; Zhu, Wg; Zhu, Xf; Zhu, X; Zhu, Y; Zoladek, T; Zong, Wx; Zorzano, A; Zschocke, J; Zuckerbraun, B.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Klionsky et al Autophagy 2012.pdf

solo utenti autorizzati

Tipologia: Versione finale editoriale
Licenza: NON PUBBLICO - Accesso privato/ristretto
Dimensione 2.32 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
2.32 MB Adobe PDF   Visualizza/Apri   Richiedi una copia

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11568/216331
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? 1678
  • Scopus 2755
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? 3632
social impact